Supernatural 6.05 Ep Reaction

[mrstotten]

 

I don't really know what to say, I have no words!!! this has never happened to me, words are my life!!!

Ok now the Never Been Kissed shout out is done

seriously people, help me understand this!!!!

I never expected this, there I was happily giggling with hubby about the twilight ribbing and preparing myself for a light hearted episode and then.....

THAT

Seriously I love Sam but I don't get this!! this is something I NEVER expected, no matter what has gone on before, for a while I suspected part Lucifer possession cos right after the smirk there was worry, fear, GENUINE concern right???? that was there right??? but then when Grandpa Campbell gave the other explanation my heart just SANK, there is no way Sam would just sacrifice Dean right? I mean that WOULD NOT HAPPEN, RIGHT??

All ideas welcome cos right now I am just unbearably sad and I want my Sam and Dean back!!! it is so bad I said that at the end of the show and hubby patted my head with a sympathetic look!!! seriously!!!

I am all for character development, but this doesn't feel like development this feels destroying everything I loved about the brothers. I want to trust show but I just.......

See no words :(

Comments

apologies to Elvis

[just-ruth.livejournal.com]

He walks like our Sammy,
Talks like our Sammy,
but I got wise -
He's a devil in disguise
Oh, yes he is
Devil in disguise.

[gwenknight.livejournal.com]

No way is that Sammy. I've thought Lucifer all along. I don't even see genuine glimpses of concern, I think they're too fake and forced. He wants Dean to think he cares but it just doesn't ring true. Plus, we don't know yet what's up with Samuel, except that he's not really Samuel, so he figures into this as well.

One good thing about last night, though, was that Dean has found his balls and he's onto Sam. And, no matter what, I think Dean's love for his brother will save Sam. Again. While I don't want to see another whole season of Sammy angst, I'd be up for Dean saving the relationship.

[cowboyangel.livejournal.com]

I have no real theories. I just really hope there's an explanation for this. I don't even think I could accept possesed!Sam or "sold his soul" Sam. I saw no regret or true concern and if Sammy was in there *at all*, there would have been. My hope is that Sam and Samuel are really something else in their likenses and the REAL Sam will be reunited with Dean soon.

[x-erikah-x.livejournal.com]

Really! I didn't see that coming either. I thought Lucifer while I watched, but there are things that still don't make sense. Good thing is, Dean is onto him.

[ras-elased.livejournal.com]

I don't even know what to think anymore. I definitely don't think it's Lucifer, if only because that's what everyone's expecting and I just can't see Show being that predictable. So I don't know if something's IN Sam, or if there's something NOT IN Sam, like his body made it to Earth but his soul or his conscience or something is still stuck in Hell. It would explain the emotional detachment, the apparent lack of love and concern for Dean (because we KNOW that shit ain't our Sammy), the downright morally bankrupt way he's been handling all their hunts lately... And he did ask for Cas' help when he first got back, but Cas didn't come. Maybe because he knows the part of Sam that really matters isn't in there? IDK, honestly. I'm just hoping we'll get a few answers next week.

[autumn-lilacs.livejournal.com]

I don't have a theory as to why Sam is behaving so oddly, but I do have a few thoughts about the smirk.

I think that he did remember Campbell's discussion about the vampire cure and he seems to have faith in Campbell's skills as a hunter, and the veracity of his claims about lore, etc. I think the smirk was one part "Oh hey, if he's one of them he can track the alpha" and one part "Oh hey, I felt like a monster for a good part of my life, let's see how you like it for a little while" knowing that it wouldn't be permanent.

I don't think he's a demon or Lucifer, simply because he's not doing a very good job at keeping his motivations a secret. He repeatedly asked Dean what he remembered about the nest, (why would a demon care about hunting vamps, etc.) and so far everyone has guessed he's not right, including Campbell who didn't even know him before this last year. (In fact, I think I recall Campbell asking Sam what was wrong with him before--about the kidnapped babies). Meg was pretty awesome at keeping her cover the last time she took Sam out for a drive, until she WANTED it to be known.

Sadly, it feels to me like the affection that he has for his brother is the memory of affection, rather than actually feeling it (or much of anything) right now.

[nachekana.livejournal.com]

Who cares? Evil!Sam is hot. Let's keep Sam evol! I love him that way. If a couple of Deans have to die in the way, whatevz!!